Munazarat Ibn Taymiyya li-Ahl al-Milal wa-al-Nihal
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- Matabi' Adwa' al-Muntada
Munazarat Ibn Taymiyya li-Ahl al-Milal wa-al-Nihal (The Debates of Ibn Taymiyya with the Adherents of Religions and Sects) is a study by Abd al-Aziz bin Muhammad Al Abd al-Latif that compiles, classifies, and annotates the theological disputations conducted by Ibn Taymiyya (d. 728 AH / 1328 CE) against various religious communities and Islamic theological factions. The first edition was published in 1426 AH (2005 CE) by Matabi' Adwa' al-Muntada in Riyadh.
Purpose and Methodology
The work was authored while Al Abd al-Latif served as an assistant professor in the Department of Creed at Imam Mohammad Ibn Saud Islamic University. The author gathered Ibn Taymiyya's oral debates from scattered passages across his treatises, collections of fatwas, and external biographical and historical sources. The title reflects the distinction between milal (non-Islamic religions) and nihal (sects originating among Muslims), terminology drawn from Ibn Taymiyya's own usage. Because the exact chronological order of many sessions could not be established, the material is arranged thematically by opposing group. Where recorded debates were particularly lengthy—such as the council over al-Aqida al-Wasitiyya or the confrontation with the Rifa'iyya—the author provided abridged summaries.
Structure and Content
The book opens with an introductory study on Ibn Taymiyya's skill in polemics, the legal permissibility of religious debating in Islamic jurisprudence, and its governing conditions. The body of the text presents seventeen primary debates, accompanied by supplementary exchanges in the commentary notes:
- Debates with Christians: Four debates addressing polytheism, the deification of Christ, and the doctrine of the hypostatic union between divinity and humanity.
- Debates with Proponents of Existential Monism: Disputations with advocates of ittihad (monistic union) and wahdat al-wujud (the unity of existence).
- Debates on Grave Veneration: Two sessions involving grave-devotees (al-Quburiyyun), one concerning the veneration of sacred stones and the other regarding extremism surrounding the tombs of the Fatimids (referred to as the Ubaydids).
- Debate with the Ahmadiyya Rifa'iyya: An abridged record of the session with members of the Rifa'iyya Sufi order concerning their practices.
- Debates with the Rafida: Two debates addressing Shi'i doctrines of the imamate.
- Debates with Deniers of Divine Attributes: Four debates against theologians denying or reinterpreting divine attributes (nufat al-sifat), including the proceedings over al-Aqida al-Wasitiyya.
The conclusion highlights Ibn Taymiyya's standard of fairness toward his interlocutors and examines the legal parameters under which disputation becomes either commendable or prohibited. Later researchers have noted that the treatise functions primarily as a concise handbook intended to highlight the core arguments and extracted benefits of these debates rather than an exhaustive academic analysis of every doctrinal dispute.
Answer updated