Fadaih al-Batiniyya
- Author died
- 505 AH
- Editions
- Mu’assasat Dār al-Kutub al-Thaqāfīyah
Fada'ih al-Batiniyya (The Infamies of the Esotericists), fully titled Fada'ih al-Batiniyya wa-Fada'il al-Mustazhiriyya (The Infamies of the Batiniyya and the Merits of the Mustazhiriyya) and also known as al-Mustazhiri, is a theological and polemical treatise written by Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (d. 505 AH / 1111 CE) to refute the doctrines of the Batiniyya (Isma'ilis) and affirm the legitimacy of the Abbasid caliphate .
Background and Composition
Al-Ghazali composed the work during his tenure in Baghdad in response to a direct directive from the Abbasid caliph al-Mustazhir bi-Allah (reigned 487–512 AH) . In both his autobiography al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error) and the opening of the treatise, al-Ghazali notes that he had already resolved to investigate the doctrines of the Ta'limiyya to uncover their arguments, making the caliphal commission an external catalyst that coincided with his internal desire . Al-Ghazali later stated in Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din (The Revival of the Religious Sciences) that material in his polemic against the Batiniyya drew upon earlier works such as Kashf al-Asrar wa-Hatk al-Astar by the Ash'ari theologian Abu Bakr al-Baqillani (d. 403 AH) .
Structure and Contents
The work is organized into ten distinct chapters (abwab), balancing rigorous dialectical argumentation with accessible exposition, while deliberately avoiding purely historical narratives of past Batini figures to focus on theological and legal refutations :
- Chapter 1: Explains the methodological framework of the book, adopting a middle path between complex dialectical demonstration and persuasive rhetorical discourse to make its refutations beneficial to both scholars and laymen .
- Chapter 2: Enumerates and explains ten titles associated with the sect across different eras—including al-Batiniyya, al-Qaramita, al-Qarmatiyya, al-Khurramiyya, al-Khurramdiniyya, al-Isma'iliyya, al-Sab'iyya, al-Babakiyya, al-Muhammira, and al-Ta'limiyya—and examines the motives underlying their movement .
- Chapter 3: Analyzes the progressive stages and stratagems of their deceptive missionary techniques (hiyal al-talbis) and the psychological and social reasons people are swayed by them .
- Chapter 4: Details the doctrinal claims of the sect across four core areas: theology (ilahiyyat), prophethood (nubuwwat), the imamate (imama), and the resurrection (hashr wa-nashr) .
- Chapter 5: Refutes their allegorical interpretations (ta'wil) of external Quranic texts, religious rituals, and legal commands, as well as their reliance on numerical and alphabetical symbolism .
- Chapter 6: Examines and refutes the rational arguments they put forward to undermine independent rational inquiry (al-nazar al-'aqli) and mandate authoritative teaching (ta'lim) .
- Chapter 7: Dismantles their arguments regarding the necessity of explicit textual designation (nass) for the infallible Imam (al-imam al-ma'sum) .
- Chapter 8: Discusses the legal rulings (fatwa al-shar') concerning adherents of the doctrine, addressing matters of apostasy, declaring them unbelievers (takfir), identifying their legal errors, and the shedding of their blood .
- Chapter 9: Establishes legal and juristic proofs (al-burhan al-fiqhi al-shar'i) for the legitimacy of the contemporary caliphate of al-Mustazhir bi-Allah .
- Chapter 10: Outlines the religious and administrative duties required of the ruler to maintain and sustain the legitimate entitlement to the imamate .
Editions
The text was edited and published by Abd al-Rahman Badawi in Cairo in 1383 AH / 1964 CE .
Answer updated