al-Uyub al-Manhajiya fi Kitabat al-Mustashriq Schacht al-Mutaalliqa bil-Sunna al-Nabawiya
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Holy Quran in Medina
al-Uyub al-Manhajiya fi Kitabat al-Mustashriq Schacht al-Mutaalliqa bil-Sunna al-Nabawiya (Methodological Flaws in the Writings of the Orientalist Schacht Concerning the Prophetic Sunna) is a critical scholarly monograph by Khalid al-Durays analyzing and refuting the methodology employed by the German Orientalist Joseph Schacht in his studies on the Prophetic Sunna and early Islamic jurisprudence .
Background and Purpose
The author frames the study around the premise that Western Orientalist scholarship on the Prophetic Sunna reached its most influential formulations through Ignaz Goldziher and Joseph Schacht, with later Western scholars viewing Schacht's work as presenting a comprehensive theory challenging the authenticity and legislative authority of the Sunna . Because Orientalist studies routinely claim adherence to rigorous academic standards, the work aims to evaluate Schacht's writings according to universally recognized principles of scientific research methodology rather than solely theological disagreements .
The book addresses a core research question: what methodological violations did Schacht commit against established rules of research in his writings on the Sunna ? In demonstrating these breaches, al-Durays draws upon definitions and principles articulated by Western methodologists and Arab specialists relying on Western methodology to establish that the violated standards are universally accepted, and to show that these flaws directly compromise the validity of Schacht's historical and legal conclusions .
Structure and Content
The book comprises an introduction, two main chapters divided into thematic sections, and a conclusion :
Chapter One: Introduction to Schacht and His Views on the Sunna
This chapter contains two sections:
- Biographical Profile of Schacht: Reviews his background, noting his birth in Ratibor on March 15, 1902, in German Silesia (later in Poland), his education at the German gymnasium, his early exposure to Eastern languages, and biographical assessments by scholars such as Bernard Lewis and Robert Brunschvig .
- Summary of His Core Views on the Sunna: Outlines Schacht's key claims, including his assertions that the Prophet was unconcerned with establishing legal systems, that Islamic law lay outside the scope of religion during most of the first century AH, that the early legal concept of sunna represented the local consensus or ideal practice of regional juristic schools rather than the Prophet's specific words and deeds, and that legal traditions back to the Prophet were invented retrospectively .
Chapter Two: Methodological Flaws in Schacht's Scholarship
This chapter examines six specific methodological defects identified in Schacht's research :
- Racial bias in underlying initial premises (al-tahayyuz al-unsuri fi al-musallamat al-awwaliya) .
- Selectivity in the choice of historical and textual sources (al-intiqa'iya fi ikhtiyar al-masadir) .
- Arbitrary and non-methodological skepticism (al-shakk ghayr al-manhaji) .
- Neglect and disregard of counter-evidence (ihmal al-adilla al-mu'arida) .
- Forced and arbitrary interpretation of texts (al-tafsir al-muta'assif lil-nusus) .
- Faulty and sweeping generalization (al-ta'mim al-fasid) .
Conclusions
The author concludes that Schacht's findings cannot be relied upon due to these fundamental methodological defects, which led to internal contradictions and a departure from scholarly objectivity . He also highlights that the practical consequence of Schacht's theories—by deeming all legal hadiths fabricated and depicting legal systems as foreign to the Prophet's mission—was to suggest that Islamic law holds no authentic religious basis and can be replaced with foreign legal codes .
Answer updated