al-Ahadith al-Warida fi Khabar al-Qahtani
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- al-Ahadith al-Warida fi Khabar al-Qahtani
al-Ahadith al-Warida fi Khabar al-Qahtani (The transmitted hadiths concerning the report of al-Qahtani) is a hadith treatise by Faisal Saeed Muhammad al-Saidi that compiles and evaluates narrations regarding the eschatological figure of al-Qahtani who is prophesied to appear before the Day of Judgment .
Overview and Scope
The author completed the treatise in Medina on 15 Ramadan 1428 AH (2007 CE) . The work focuses on hadiths dealing with the signs of the Hour (ashrat al-sa'a), specifically examining the emergence of a man from the Qahtan tribe at the end of time . The author collects both sound and weak narrations on the subject, provides source takhrij, assesses isnad authenticity, and contextualizes them using commentaries by classical scholars .
Contents and Analysis
The treatise addresses several key themes across the collected reports:
-
The Prophetic Report and its Hadith Evaluation: The author analyzes the primary authentic narration transmitted from Abu Hurayra in Sahih al-Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, and the Musnad of Ahmad ibn Hanbal: لا تقوم الساعة حتى يخرج رجل من قحطان يسوق الناس بعصاه ("The Hour will not be established until a man from Qahtan emerges driving the people with his staff") . The author classifies it as one of the signs of prophethood (a'lam al-nubuwwa) . He also grades related narrations found in al-Tabarani's al-Mu'jam al-Awsat and al-Mu'jam al-Kabir as weak due to the presence of Salama ibn al-Fadl and the 'an'ana (transmission using "from") of Ibn Ishaq . A narration transmitted by Qays ibn Jabir al-Sadafi is likewise deemed weak, citing assessments by al-Haythami and al-Albani .
-
Scholarly Interpretations of al-Qahtani: The work discusses classical scholarly opinions regarding the identity and nature of al-Qahtani . Citing Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani and al-Qurtubi, the author notes that "driving people with his staff" denotes his overpowering dominance and people's subjugation to him . The treatise addresses al-Qurtubi's suggestion that al-Qahtani might be identical to al-Jahjah, along with Ibn Hajar's objection that al-Jahjah is described as a client (mawla) whereas Qahtan represents free Arabs . It also cites discussions by Ibn Kathir from al-Nihaya fi al-Fitan wa-l-Malahim and al-Maqdisi from Kitab al-Bad' wa-l-Ta'rikh .
-
Reconciliation with Caliphal Lineage and Mu'awiya's Stance: The author examines reports concerning Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan's initial disapproval of narrations stating that a Qahtani would rule, reconciling it through Ibn Hajar's explanation that Quraysh's exclusive right to leadership is conditional upon upholding the religion, and noting that Mu'awiya likely had not heard the specific prophetic report . Commentary by Ibn Battal citing al-Muhallab is also brought to bear on the issue .
-
Timing and Duration: Drawing upon reports compiled in Nu'aym ibn Hammad's Kitab al-Fitan, the author considers reports mentioning that al-Qahtani emerges after the Mahdi and rules for twenty years, though highlighting that no authentic chain establishes the exact duration .
-
Refutation of Historical Misidentifications: The author includes a fatwa from al-Durar al-Saniyya by the Najdi scholar Sa'd ibn Hamad ibn Atiq, refuting claims made by contemporaries who attempted to project the prophecy onto the historical ruler Muhammad ibn Rashid .
Conclusions
In the conclusion of the treatise, the author summarizes six main findings :
- The report of al-Qahtani is authentic and constitutes one of the signs of the Hour that must be affirmed .
- His emergence occurs at the end of time prior to the Day of Judgment .
- People will follow and submit to his rule .
- The exact duration of his rule is not fixed by any soundly established text .
- No decisive textual evidence definitively identifies whether he is a believer, Muslim, or disbeliever .
- His governance is established through conquest and political domination (al-ghalaba wa-l-mulk), rather than election by the community's electors (ahl al-hall wa-l-'aqd) .
Answer updated