Tawsif al-Aqdiya fi al-Sharia al-Islamiyya
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- (بدون)
Tawsif al-Aqdiya fi al-Sharia al-Islamiyya (Legal Qualification of Judicial Cases in Islamic Law) is a specialized contemporary legal treatise on Islamic judicial procedure and adjudication by the Saudi jurist and judge Abd Allah ibn Muhammad al-Khunayn (b. 1376 AH / 1957 CE) . The work investigates the principles and branches governing the application of universal legal rulings (al-ahkam al-kulliyya) to particular judicial facts and requests for legal opinions (al-waqai al-qadaiyya wa-al-fatwiyya), integrating theoretical frameworks with applied cases from early Islamic history and modern Saudi courts .
Purpose and Scope
The author composed the treatise to formulate a comprehensive methodology for the judicial characterization (tawsif) of legal disputes, defined as vesting established factual incidents with the legal descriptions stipulated in Sharia rulings . Al-Khunayn observed that while legal theory (usul al-fiqh) regulates the derivation of universal rulings from primary sources, and substantive jurisprudence (fiqh) classifies human actions, the discipline of judicial qualification governs the actual projection and descent of those abstract rulings onto real-life incidents .
The book draws upon earlier treatments of practical application (tahqiq al-manat), such as discussions in al-Muwafaqat by Abu Ishaq al-Shatibi and Muzil al-Malam an Hukkam al-Anam by Ibn Khaldun, seeking to systematically categorize, theorize, and supply practical applications for judges and muftis .
Structure and Contents
The work is organized into an introduction (tamhid), four major thematic parts (abwab), and a conclusion :
- Introduction: Defines judicial qualification and its equivalent designations (such as applying universal rulings, applying rulings to their loci, and tahqiq al-manat), its Sharia legitimacy, its divisions (procedural, substantive, and incidental; preliminary and final; positive and negative), its distinction from legislative, juristic, and fatwa qualifications, and its practical utility .
- Part One (Universal Rulings and Their Signifiers): Analyzes declaratory rulings (al-hukm al-wad'i)—comprising causes, conditions, and impediments—and prescriptive rulings (al-hukm al-taklifi), along with evidentiary proofs of legal norms and methods for establishing universal rulings through ijtihad, adherence (ittiba'), imitation (taqlid), affiliation to legal schools (madhahib), juristic derivation (takhrij), and handling unprecedented cases; it also details the hermeneutical interpretation of Sharia and juristic texts .
- Part Two (Judicial Facts and Incidents): Examines the classification, evidentiary verification, and factual extraction of judicial incidents, followed by the interpretation of human conduct in litigation, including speech, actions, gestures, silence, motives, witness testimony, and the resolution of conflicting evidence .
- Part Three (Determining Judicial Qualification): Details the substantive principles of judicial qualification—such as taking into account consequences (ma'alat), the higher objectives of Sharia (maqasid), individual and circumstantial variations, necessities and needs, and the warding off of prescribed penalties through doubt—as well as judicial analogy, direct ijtihad, the respective roles of litigants, witnesses, and judges, procedures for scrutinizing qualification, its relation to judicial verdicts and judicial reasoning (tasbib), and the stages of qualification .
- Part Four (Applied Judicial Cases): Presents practical case studies divided chronologically into rulings from the Companions and Successors, cases from later historical jurists, and modern judicial applications drawn from contemporary Saudi courts .
Method and Publication
Al-Khunayn adopted an analytical, inductive, and comparative methodology, substantiating principles with scriptural evidence and juristic literature across schools while focusing predominantly on practical procedural application . The book was published in three volumes in Riyadh, with its first edition appearing in 1423 AH (2003 CE) .
Answer updated