Tahqiq al-Ayat al-Bayyinat fi Adam Sama al-Amwat
- Author died
- 1317 AH
- Editions
- al-Maktab al-Islami
Tahqiq al-Ayat al-Bayyinat fi Adam Sama al-Amwat (Arabic: تحقيق الآيات البينات في عدم سماع الأموات, lit. 'Verification of the Clear Verses Regarding the Dead Not Hearing') is a theological and jurisprudential treatise by the Iraqi scholar Ibn al-Alusi (1252–1317 AH / 1836–1899 CE) examining the question of whether the deceased can hear the living, primarily from the perspective of the Hanafi school and classical Islamic scholarship .
Background and Composition
The treatise originated following an incident during Ramadan 1305 AH (1888 CE), when Ibn al-Alusi mentioned in a public teaching session in Baghdad the position recorded in classical Hanafi legal manuals that the dead do not hear the speech of the living . As evidence of this legal stance, he cited the Hanafi ruling regarding oaths: if a person swears never to speak to someone and subsequently addresses him after his death, the person does not breach their oath because speech implies conveying understanding, which is inapplicable to the deceased .
After critics rejected this attribution and claimed that neither Abu Hanifa nor the founders of the other three legal schools (Malik ibn Anas, al-Shafi'i, and Ahmad ibn Hanbal) held such a view, rumors circulated among the public . Ibn al-Alusi composed the treatise to document the statements, textual citations, and arguments of Hanafi authorities and other major jurists in detail .
Structure and Content
The author organized the work into three chapters (fusul) and a conclusion (khatimah) :
- First Chapter: Gathers texts and rulings from classical Hanafi jurists establishing that the deceased do not hear the speech of the living, drawing upon standard legal chapters such as oaths and funeral rulings .
- Second Chapter: Records citations from scholars across the Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali schools who concurred with this stance, discussing the transmissions from A'ishah, al-Maziri, al-Qadi Abu Ya'la, and Muhammad al-Saffarini .
- Third Chapter and Conclusion: Evaluates counterarguments, hadiths, and transmitted reports cited by proponents of hearing, such as the Prophet's address to the slain pagans at the well of Badr .
Ibn al-Alusi grounds the general rule of non-hearing in Quranic verses such as وَمَا أَنْتَ بِمُسْمِعٍ مَنْ فِي الْقُبُورِ ("And you cannot make those hear who are in graves") and إِنَّكَ لَا تُسْمِعُ الْمَوْتَى ("Indeed, you cannot make the dead hear") . In addressing why Muslims are instructed to convey greetings of peace (taslim) at graves if the dead cannot hear, he suggests that this address is an act of devotional ritual compliance (amr ta'abbudi), comparing it to silently reciting greetings in prayer behind an imam where adjacent worshippers do not hear the recitation .
Reception and Editions
The treatise was edited and annotated in the twentieth century by the hadith scholar Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani and published by al-Maktab al-Islami . Later scholars have also utilized and abridged its material in discussions regarding the affairs of the intermediate realm (al-barzakh) and polemics surrounding invoking the deceased (istighathah) .
Answer updated