Qawaid Marifat al-Bida
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- Dār Ibn al-Jawzī lil-Nashr wal-Tawzīʿ
Qawaid Marifat al-Bida (Qawāʿid Maʿrifat al-Bidaʿ, "Principles for Identifying Innovations") is a contemporary treatise on legal theory (uṣūl al-fiqh) and creed by Muhammad Husayn al-Jizani, dedicated to formulating systematic legal-theoretical principles for discerning religious innovation (bidʿah).
Purpose and Scope
Al-Jizani composed the work to establish clear parameters for distinguishing between the Prophetic Sunnah and religious innovations, aiming to resolve widespread confusion and conflicting extremes. In his introduction, he identifies two flawed approaches among people: one group goes to an extreme by excessively declaring novel issues to be innovations even when based on legal evidence—thereby categorizing aspects of the Sunnah and Sharia as bidʿah—while another group is overly lenient, narrowing the concept of bidʿah to major doctrinal heresies and consequently subsuming novelties into legitimate religious practice.
Structure and Content
The treatise is organized into an introduction, two preliminary overviews (madkhalān), the primary body of twenty-three maxims, and a conclusion.
The first preliminary overview addresses the definition and limits of innovation across eight topics:
- The lexical definition of bidʿah.
- Its legal (sharʿī) definition.
- A comparison between its lexical and legal meanings.
- The relationship between inventing religious practices (ibtidāʿ) and origination (iḥdāth).
- The relationship between innovation and the Sunnah.
- The relationship between innovation and sin (maʿṣiyah).
- The relationship between innovation and unrestricted public interest (al-maṣlaḥah al-mursalah).
- The distinguishing characteristics of innovation.
The second preliminary overview elaborates on three comprehensive foundational origins (al-uṣūl al-jāmiʿah) that give rise to religious innovations: seeking nearness to God through unlegislated means, departing from the order of the religion, and the pretexts leading to innovation.
The core of the book classifies twenty-three governing rules under these three comprehensive foundations:
- Seeking nearness to God through unlegislated acts (10 rules): Covers worship based on fabricated hadiths, acts based on mere personal opinion or desire, acts contradicting the Sunnah of omission (al-sunnah al-tarkiyyah), worship conflicting with the practice of the righteous predecessors (al-Salaf al-Salih), acts contradicting Sharia principles, seeking devotion through purely customary or permissible matters, worship via sinful acts, unbinding a legally restricted act of worship, restricting an unrestricted act of worship, and extremism (ghuluww) in religious devotion.
- Departing from the order of the religion (8 rules): Encompasses beliefs and opinions contradicting scriptural texts, doctrines neither found in revelation nor transmitted from the Companions and Successors, disputation and argumentation in religion, imposing customary habits or commercial transactions as mandatory, altering established legal positions through custom, imitating non-Muslims in their distinctive qualities, imitating non-Muslims in their religious novelties, and reviving practices of pre-Islamic ignorance (jāhiliyyah).
- Pretexts leading to innovation (5 rules): Addresses performing an act required by Sharia in a manner that falsely suggests otherwise, performing a permissible act in a way that suggests it is legally obligatory, scholars committing public sins such that the public believes they are part of religion, widespread sins among the public left unrebuked by scholars able to denounce them, and subsidiary actions resulting from introduced innovations.
The book closes with a summary overview of these rules and an outline of the domains in which innovation occurs.
Reception and Publication
Qawaid Marifat al-Bida was published by Dar Ibn al-Jawzi in Dammam in a single volume, with its first edition appearing in 1419 AH (1998 CE). It has been referenced by later researchers as a key modern work on the codification of rules regarding religious innovations alongside classical and contemporary studies such as al-Shatibi's al-I'tisam.
Answer updated