Fikrat Kamnwelth Islami

Author died
1393 AH
Editions
Dār al-Fikr al-Mu‘āṣir

Fikrat Kamnwelth Islami (The Idea of an Islamic Commonwealth) is a political and civilizational treatise by the Algerian thinker Malik Bennabi (1323–1393 AH / 1905–1973 CE), published as part of his series Mushkilāt al-Ḥaḍārah (Problems of Civilization) to propose a federal geopolitical framework for the contemporary Muslim world .

Background and Composition

Bennabi developed the conceptual outline of the book in the late 1950s while residing in Cairo . During this time, he gave his handwritten draft to his student Omar Meskawi to type, personally correcting the terminology to "Commonwealth" on the typed sheets .

Bennabi noted in the introduction that the work was not intended to present a ready-made administrative solution, but rather to formulate a foundational inquiry requiring specialized institutional research and collective scientific study across the Muslim world . He argued that the Muslim world was undergoing a transitional phase marked by maladaptation and civilizational ineffectiveness, requiring methodical planning to overcome psychological complexes in an increasingly structured world .

Geopolitical Rationale and Premise

The book's thesis is grounded in an analysis of the post–World War II global order, where power was consolidated around the Washington–Moscow axis and structured into expansive geopolitical blocs, including the North Atlantic treaty zone, the Soviet bloc, the People's Republic of China, and the Indian Union . Bennabi observed that the Muslim world at the close of the 1950s remained outside these planned power units, causing individual Muslims to internalize a sense of marginality in global affairs .

According to Bennabi, this psychological state leaves the Muslim world facing two possibilities: either mounting an organic internal transformation tailored to its own socio-psychological conditions, or succumbing to an uncontrollable external revolution due to the absence of strategic leadership . Consequently, civilizational unification is presented as both a psychological necessity to alleviate internal fractures and a technical geopolitical imperative .

Structure of the Proposed Commonwealth

Bennabi argued that while the Muslim world retains an underlying spiritual unity, it is practically divided into multiple distinct cultural and geographic zones:

  • The Black / African Muslim world
  • The Arab Muslim world
  • The Iranian Muslim world (comprising Persians, Afghans, and Pakistanis)
  • The Malayan Muslim world (comprising Indonesia and Malaya)
  • The East Asian ("Yellow") Muslim world

Because of this diversity alongside spiritual coherence, Bennabi rejected both centralized hegemony and broad pan-Islamist schemes such as the "Islamistan" project advocated at times by Pakistani leaders . He likewise rejected any model radiating from a single geographic center—such as Mecca during the early Islamic era—noting that modern political realities would cause such centralization to be interpreted as the imposition of a particular local will .

Instead, he proposed a decentralized federal commonwealth structure headed by a collective body, such as the Islamic Conference, acting as a federal apparatus . The constitutional framework of this union would rely on a modern legal reassessment of the concept of the Imamate (al-imāmah), supported by practical regional and economic bonds, such as ties between Egypt and Sudan or nationalist ties among Arab states .

Publication and Translation

The book was translated from Bennabi's French text into Arabic by al-Tayyib al-Sharif and was first published in 1960 . It was later reissued under the supervision of the Malik Bennabi Seminar (Nadwat Mālik ibn Nabī) by Dār al-Fikr in Damascus and Dār al-Fikr al-Mu‘āṣir in Beirut, with an introductory preface by Omar Meskawi dated February 1990, and a second reprint appearing in 1431 AH / 2000 CE .

Answer updated