al-Muqtarab fi Bayan al-Mudtarib
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- Dar Ibn Hazm lil-Tiba'ah wa-al-Nashr
al-Muqtarab fi Bayan al-Mudtarib (The Approach to Clarifying the Confounded Hadith) is a specialized hadith terminology and criticism study authored by the contemporary Saudi scholar Ahmad bin Umar Bazmul. The work examines the mudtarib (confounded or discordant) hadith—a category of defective transmission arising from irreconcilable narrator divergence—along with its analytical rules and the narrators associated with it.
Background and Context
The book originated as an academic Master's thesis presented at Umm al-Qura University in Mecca in 1419 AH under the title al-Hadith al-Mudtarib: Dirasa wa-Tatbiqan 'ala al-Sunan al-Arba' (The Mudtarib Hadith: A Theoretical and Applied Study on the Four Sunan). It was later published under the fuller title al-Muqtarab fi Bayan al-Mudtarib: Ta'rifuhu, Qawa'iduhu, Amthilatuhu, wa-al-Rijal al-Mawsufuna bi-al-Idtirab (The Approach to Clarifying the Confounded: Its Definition, Rules, Examples, and Men Described with Idtirab).
The author adopted the title from a classical treatise bearing the same name by Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (d. 852 AH), an unlocated work that gathered examples of idtirab from al-Daraqutni's al-Ilal (The Defects).
Contents and Structure
The book consists of an introduction, a preliminary overview, two primary divisions, a conclusion, and analytical indices:
- Preliminary Overview (Tamhid): Covers the division of reports by transmission paths (mutawatir and ahad), the causes of narrator impairment and hadith weakness (omissions and disparagements), and forms of narrator divergence (mukhalafat al-thuqat).
- Part One (al-Qism al-Awwal): A theoretical and methodological study of the mudtarib hadith, arranged in three sections:
- Section 1: Linguistic and technical definitions of idtirab, its subcategories and rulings, and historical writings dedicated to it.
- Section 2: Scholarly doctrines on narrator variation (al-ikhtilaf 'ala al-rawi), its impact on the narrator and the transmitted text, and methods for identifying mudtarib narrators.
- Section 3: Foundational rules for identifying idtirab in the chain of transmission (isnad), the text (matn), and both combined.
- Part Two (al-Qism al-Thani): A biographical survey of hadith narrators described as suffering from idtirab, prefaced by an exploration of narrator precision (dabt), error, and the causes of inconsistency:
- Section 1: Narrators described with idtirab unconditionally (mutlaqan).
- Section 2: Narrators described with idtirab conditionally (bi-qayd), such as in transmissions from specific teachers.
Method
In gathering and analyzing material, Bazmul traced the rulings and statements of hadith critics across primary manuals of hadith terminology, biographical dictionaries (kutub al-rijal), defect literature (kutub al-ilal), and extensive hadith commentaries. For traditions weakened due to idtirab, he evaluated supporting and parallel paths (mutaba'at and shawahid) and provided contextual biographical profiles (jarh wa-ta'dil) for less familiar figures.
Publication
The work was published in a single volume of 489 pages in 1422 AH / 2001 CE, co-issued by Dar al-Kharraz in Jeddah and Dar Ibn Hazm in Beirut.
Answer updated