al-Khitab al-Qurani li-Ahl al-Kitab wa Mawqifuhum minhu Qadiman wa Hadithan
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- al-Khitab al-Qurani li-Ahl al-Kitab wa Mawqifuhum minhu Qadiman wa Hadithan
al-Khitab al-Qurani li-Ahl al-Kitab wa Mawqifuhum minhu Qadiman wa Hadithan (The Quranic Discourse to the People of the Book and Their Stance Toward It in the Past and Present) is an academic study by Hud Muhammad Abu Ras that examines the Quranic address directed at Jews and Christians and analyzes their historical and contemporary responses to it . Originally submitted in 2011 as a doctoral dissertation in the Department of Quran and Hadith at the Academy of Islamic Studies, University of Malaya in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, the work explores the thematic, stylistic, and theological dimensions of the Quranic address to the People of the Book .
Purpose and Methodology
The work aims to compile and categorize the Quranic verses addressing the People of the Book into thematic topics and connect them to the characteristics and stances of Jews and Christians across history . The author outlines several motivations for the study, including defending the Quran against claims of textual alteration, responding to criticisms targeting the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, and addressing contemporary arguments concerning the preservation and meanings of the Torah and the Gospel .
Abu Ras employs an inductive and analytical methodology (al-manhaj al-istiqra'i al-tahlili):
- Inductive analysis: Gathering all relevant Quranic passages that address the People of the Book, whether through direct address, through intermediaries, or in the third person .
- Analytical and thematic classification: Analyzing the semantic meanings, recurring names (such as Ahl al-Kitab, Bani Isra'il, al-Yahud, al-Nasara, and Ahl al-Injeel), and linguistic forms (such as vocatives, commands, prohibitions, interrogatives, and conditional clauses), alongside classical commentaries (tafsir) and historical applications .
Structure and Contents
The study comprises an introductory framework, five main chapters, and a concluding synthesis :
- Chapter 1: Forms and Styles of Quranic Discourse: Examines the linguistic terms, stylistic modes, and communicative channels of the address—distinguishing between addresses coming directly from God, delivered via the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, Moses, or Jesus, conveyed through the believers, or recounted via third-person narration—alongside definitions and historical backgrounds of Judaism and Christianity .
- Chapter 2: The Call to Faith and Dialogue: Covers the Quranic call to the People of the Book to embrace monotheism (tawhid), warnings against religious extremism (ghuluww) in ancient and modern contexts, and the Quranic guidelines for debate and polemical engagement with them .
- Chapter 3: Belief in the Quran and Prior Scriptures: Analyzes verses commanding belief in divine revelation, documents stances taken by fair-minded figures among the People of the Book toward the Quran in past and modern eras, and discusses modern efforts to distort the Quran .
- Chapter 4: Textual Alteration of Previous Scriptures: Reviews the types of textual distortion (tahrif) attributed to earlier scriptures, provides historical and contemporary examples of modifications to the Torah and the Gospel, and cites testimonies from Western and Christian scholars regarding these changes .
- Chapter 5: Quranic Discourse Regarding Ethics: Explores the ethical dimensions addressed in the Quran, focusing particularly on the breach of covenants and pacts (naqd al-uhud wa-l-mawathiq) in past and present times .
Key Conclusions
The author concludes that the Quranic discourse to the People of the Book is comprehensive and universal, addressing their beliefs, worship, interactions, and morals while providing clear directives and remedies . The study argues that the core theological stances and moral behaviors of the People of the Book in contemporary times remain fundamentally continuous with those of their predecessors, characterized primarily by persistence in religious excess and rejection of the Quranic message .
Answer updated