al-Jarh wa al-Tadil - al-Lahim
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- Maktabat al-Rushd
al-Jarh wa al-Tadil (Impugnment and Accreditation) is a treatise on the principles and practical methodology of hadith narrator criticism by the contemporary Saudi scholar Ibrahim al-Lahim (b. 1376 AH / 1956 CE), published as the first installment in his series Silsilat Naqd al-Marwiyyat (Criticism of Transmissions Series) .
Background and Purpose
The author composed the work to address what he identified as a shortcoming in contemporary studies of hadith criticism, where researchers often approach narrator evaluation, chain continuity, and hidden defects as fragmented specializations rather than an integrated discipline . al-Lahim observed that early hadith scholars applied critical rules derived generally from scriptural texts in their practical appraisals without compiling them into standalone theoretical treatises . He planned a five-part series to systematically articulate these principles: the first on al-jarh wa al-tadil, the second on continuity and severance of transmission (al-ittisal wa al-inqita'), the third on comparative collation of transmissions (muqaranat al-marwiyyat), the fourth on critical masters and their literature (a'immat al-naqd wa kutubuhum), and the fifth on miscellaneous topics in hadith criticism .
Structure and Contents
The book consists of an introduction and four main chapters :
- Chapter One: Judging the Narrator (al-Hukm 'ala al-rawi): Examines the practical methods employed by early critics to evaluate narrators, including testing them through prompting (talqin), comparing a narrator against contemporaries, tracking variations in a narrator's state across time or geography, and the phenomenon of secondary review and critique of previous critics' verdicts (naqd al-naqd) .
- Chapter Two: Critics' Judgments on Narrators and Their Tiers (Ahkam al-nuqqad 'ala al-ruwah wa-maratibuha): Divided into three sections covering theoretical verdicts expressed directly by critics, practical stances such as narrating from or omitting a narrator, and the categorization of critical terms into evaluative tiers .
- Chapter Three: Principles for Examining Critics' Judgments (Dawabit al-nazar fi ahkam al-nuqqad 'ala al-ruwah): Contains an introduction and four sections addressing the four dimensions of analyzing critical reports: verifying the transmission from the attributed critic (thubut al-nass), ensuring textual integrity against corruption (salamah al-nass), identifying the particular status and habits of the critic (qa'il al-nass), and interpreting the precise intended meaning of the critical phrase (dalalat al-nass) .
- Chapter Four: Distinguishing Narrators in the Chain (Tamyiz ruwat al-isnad): Covers the frequent occurrence of homonymous confusion among narrators, the underlying causes of such mix-ups, and the technical methods used to disambiguate shared or similar names .
Method
al-Lahim's methodology emphasizes grounding rules in extensive induction (sabr) from the statements and actual practices of early critics during the formative period of transmission . The text arranges quotes from early critics across historical tiers in chronological sequence, avoids transforming flexible applications into rigid formulas, and provides ample practical examples . The author also incorporates and discusses earlier syntheses of critical principles by classical authorities—such as Ibn Shahin, Abu al-Walid al-Baji, Shams al-Din al-Dhahabi, and Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani—as well as modern studies such as Dawabit al-Jarh wa al-Tadil by Abd al-Aziz ibn Muhammad al-Abd al-Latif .
Publication
The work was completed in Buraydah in the Al-Qassim Province of Saudi Arabia and published in a single volume by Maktabat al-Rushd in Riyadh, with its first edition appearing in 1424 AH (2003 CE) .
Answer updated