al-Istighrab
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- al-Istighrab
Al-Istighrab (Occidentalism) is a contemporary academic treatise by Abd al-Majid bin Muhammad al-Wa'lan that examines the study of the Western world from an Islamic perspective, addressing its conceptual foundations, methodological guidelines, and practical necessity.
Purpose and Scope
The author composed the treatise to define Occidentalism as an emerging field of inquiry and to formulate a sound Islamic stance toward studying the West. Al-Wa'lan defines Occidentalism (al-istighrab) as the counterpart to Orientalism (al-istishraq), characterizing it as the systematic, documented, and objective study of the West (Europe and the Americas) across its creedal, legislative, historical, geographical, economic, political, and cultural facets.
A central premise of the work is distinguishing Occidentalism from Westernization (al-taghrib). Whereas Westernization refers to ideological, social, and cultural currents aimed at assimilating Muslims into Western habits and eroding Islamic identity, Occidentalism is framed as an active, scholarly endeavor to understand Western civilization without adopting its creedal or cultural presuppositions.
Structure and Content
The treatise is organized into an introduction, five chapters, and a conclusion:
- Chapter One: Definition and Origins of Occidentalism – Explores the definitions of Occidentalism and Westernization, highlights the distinction between the two, and traces the historical background of studying other nations. Al-Wa'lan notes classical Islamic heresiographical traditions (such as works by Ibn Hazm, Abd al-Qahir al-Baghdadi, and Ibn Taymiyyah) and observations of European societies by medieval figures like Usama ibn Munqidh, as well as modern nineteenth-century accounts by Rifa'a al-Tahtawi and Khayr al-Din al-Tunisi. It also notes contemporary theoretical formulations, notably by Hasan Hanafi in his work Muqaddimah fi 'Ilm al-Istighrab (Introduction to the Science of Occidentalism).
- Chapter Two: The Importance of Occidentalism – Argues for the necessity of understanding Western civilization's internal historical drivers, strengths, and vulnerabilities in order to convey the Islamic message effectively, counter intellectual fascination with the West, and adopt beneficial material knowledge while safeguarding Islamic tenets.
- Chapter Three: The Sound Position Toward Occidentalism – Contrasts how Western scholars historically appropriated scientific and worldly knowledge from Islamic civilization without compromising their own foundational beliefs against the modern Muslim world's often uncritical adoption of Western thought. It reviews contemporary debates, citing proponents such as Mazen Mutabaqani and Ja'far Sheikh Idris, as well as critics such as Hashim Salih.
- Chapter Four: Methodological Guidelines – Sets forth foundational religious and academic controls required for researchers undertaking Occidentalist studies.
- Chapter Five: Case Studies in the Study of the West – Applies the proposed framework to analyze Western social conditions, using statistical reports and studies on topics such as marriage and family breakdown, crime rates, racial discrimination, capitalism's social impacts, and ethical crises.
Methodological Guidelines
Al-Wa'lan outlines six essential controls for conducting Occidentalist research:
- Sincerity of intention (al-Ikhlas): Directing research toward defending religious truths and guiding people rather than seeking debate, prestige, or material gain.
- Knowledge (al-'Ilm): Firm grounding in the primary sources of Islam (the Quran and the Sunnah) as well as proficiency in the languages, sociology, and doctrines of the societies being studied.
- Assessment of benefit and harm (Taqdir al-maslahah wa-al-mafsadah): Weighing the potential intellectual hazards of engaging with foreign ideologies and consulting qualified scholars.
- Reliance on primary sources (al-Ruju' ila al-masadir): Directly citing authentic texts and accurately attributing arguments in their original phrasing.
- Freedom from bias and desire (al-Tajarrud min al-hawa): Avoiding partiality that compromises sound judgment.
- Justice and fairness (al-'Adl wa-al-insaf): Maintaining scientific integrity and equitable assessment, even when examining adversaries.
In the conclusion, the author emphasizes that genuine understanding of Western civilization cannot be gained through casual travel or superficial readings, but requires dedicated institutional research that combines firm Islamic grounding with rigorous empirical and sociological study.
Answer updated