Ahkam al-Tayammum Dirasah Fiqhiyyah Muqaranah
- Author died
- -
- Editions
- Dār al-Ṣumay‘ī lil-Nashr wa-al-Tawzī‘
Ahkam al-Tayammum: Dirasah Fiqhiyyah Muqaranah (Rulings on Dry Ablution: A Comparative Jurisprudential Study) is a comprehensive treatise on Islamic legal rulings pertaining to dry ablution (tayammum) by the Saudi contemporary scholar Raid bin Hamdan al-Hazmi. Originally submitted as an academic master's thesis, the work examines the subject through a comparative analysis across the four recognized Sunni schools of Islamic jurisprudence (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali).
Origins and Composition
The work originated as a master's thesis submitted to the Center for Islamic Studies at the Faculty of Sharia and Islamic Studies at Umm al-Qura University in Mecca. The research was supervised by Muhammad Abdullah Wuld Karim. Al-Hazmi defended the thesis on 6 Jumada al-Akhirah 1429 AH, receiving an Excellent grade (97%) with First Class Honors and a recommendation for publication.
Purpose and Scope
Al-Hazmi authored the book to provide an exhaustive, contemporary comparative study of dry purification, noting its role as an exclusive dispensation granted to the Muslim community and as an alleviation of hardship. While reviewing previous literature, he consulted earlier research such as Musaid bin Qasim al-Falih's al-Tayammum: Ahkamuhu wa-Masa'iluh (143 pages), observing that it primarily relied on the Hanbali school, omitted full evidence for differing opinions, and left out approximately one hundred legal sub-issues that al-Hazmi incorporated into his own study.
Methodology
Al-Hazmi adheres to a systematic comparative legal methodology:
- For issues of consensus (ijma') or agreement, he presents the ruling alongside its textual evidence, underlying legal rationale (ta'lil), and documentation from classical sources.
- For contested issues (khilaf), he delineates the exact point of contention (tahrir mahall al-niza'), identifies the cause of disagreement (sabab al-khilaf) where possible, presents the positions of the four Sunni schools documented directly from their respective references, and evaluates their proofs from the Quran, the Sunnah, scholarly reports (athar), and rational deductions (ma'qul).
- He reviews and addresses potential critiques of the arguments, using specific phrasing to distinguish between previously recorded scholarly critiques and his own deductions, before indicating his preferred position (tarjih) based on the strength of evidence.
- He references Quranic verses by chapter and verse number, attributes hadiths and provides gradings for narrations not found in Sahih al-Bukhari or Sahih Muslim, glosses obscure terminology, and provides biographical notices for cited scholars, excluding well-known companions of the Prophet, the four eponymous imams, and the compilers of the six canonical hadith books.
Structure and Contents
The book opens with an introduction covering previous scholarship and methodology, followed by a preliminary overview, six main chapters (abwab), a conclusion, and nine thematic indexes.
- Preliminary Overview (al-Tamhid): Covers the linguistic and juristic definitions of tayammum, textual evidence and wisdom behind its legislation, and its status as an exclusive feature of the Muslim Ummah. Al-Hazmi selects the technical definition: "intending clean earth to wipe the face and hands under specific conditions in a specific manner."
- Chapter 1: Causes Necessitating Tayammum (al-Asbab al-Mujibah li-l-Tayammum): Details the three legal causes permitting tayammum: lack of water (including searching for water, purchasing it, borrowing for it, forgetting its location, having insufficient amounts, or disposing of it); physical inability to use water (the sick, the wounded, and those with splints); and fear of harm from using water (fear of thirst, extreme cold, or missing mandatory, eid, funeral, or Friday prayers).
- Chapter 2: Legal Rulings of Tayammum (Ahkam al-Tayammum): Discusses whether tayammum is a concession (rukhsah) or an original obligation ('azimah); whether it acts as a substitute that removes ritual impurity or merely permits prayer; its application for major and minor ritual impurities; its use for physical filth (najasah); and rulings concerning tayammum while traveling or resident.
- Chapter 3: Conditions of Tayammum (Shurut al-Tayammum): Examines eight conditions: intention (niyyah); Islam; legal capacity (taklif); cessation of menstrual and postnatal bleeding; removal of physical barriers on the limbs; searching for water and failing to find it; entry of prayer time; and performing tayammum with clean earth (sa'id), including rulings on various earth substances, dust, snow, and impure or usurped soil.
- Chapter 4: Obligatory Elements of Tayammum (Furud al-Tayammum): Discusses three obligatory components: wiping the face and hands completely (including strike limits, hair coverage, and severed limbs); order (tartib); and uninterrupted continuity (muwalah).
- Chapter 5: Recommended and Disliked Acts (Sunan al-Tayammum wa-Makruhatuh): Analyzes recommended acts (such as the basmalah, beginning with the right limb, facing the qiblah, shaking off excess dust, and interlacing fingers) and disliked practices (such as renewing tayammum without cause or repeating the wiping).
- Chapter 6: Nullifiers of Tayammum and the One Lacking Both Purifiers (Mubtilat al-Tayammum wa-Faqid al-Tahurayn): Details invalidators of tayammum (occurrences that nullify wudu, finding water before, during, or after prayer, expiration of prayer time, cessation of the justifying excuse, apostasy, long interruptions, and removing footwear) as well as the rulings and prayer description for one who lacks both water and clean earth (faqid al-tahurayn).
- Conclusion and Indexes: Summarizes the findings and contains separate indexes for Quranic verses, hadiths, non-prophetic reports (athar), biographical entries, geographical locations, rare words, poetic verses, cited bibliography, and topics.
Reception and Publication
The work was introduced and commended by Sheikh Abdullah bin Sulayman al-Mani', a member of the Saudi Council of Senior Scholars, on 27 Jumada al-Ula 1430 AH. Al-Mani' praised the author's grounding in legal principles, mastery of the higher objectives of Islamic law (maqasid), thoroughness in presenting differences of opinion, and scholarly weight, remarking that its depth exceeded that of many doctoral dissertations.
The first edition was published in 1432 AH / 2011 CE (with a 1430 AH cataloging date) by Dar al-Sumay'i for Publishing and Distribution in Riyadh, in a single volume comprising 754 pages.
Answer updated